Should children only read about the life they know?

Primary school teachers in the UK have criticised an English test of 10- and 11-year-olds because the text included background that was not part of the children’s culture. They said it was unfair as the children had no experience of the setting.

It made me wonder if children should only be exposed to stories from their own way of life. I remember being given an excerpt from The Kontiki Expedition to answer question on when I was about 11. It was the first time I had read about travel adventure, and it opened my little world – people travelled for adventure! I’d thought they only travelled to visit relatives or for work. I knew nothing about the Pacific current, the Peru and Tahiti. But that brief passage from the book stayed with me, as did the author’s name, Thor Heyerdahl. Last year, I found the book, reissued, and took nothing but joy in reading the recreation of a transport passage from South America to the Pacific Isles.

Similarly reading Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn, what is a little Scottish girl supposed to know about the culture of the American south in the 19^th century. However, I loved every minute of the adventure, have reread both novels as an adult and read more work by Mark Twain. And it is thanks, I believe, to that childhood exposure.

When my children were growing up in Texas, I feared their only heroes were the ones they saw on television – those who wore jumpsuits in primary colours or lived in turtle shells. So I began telling them Greek myths, starting with Theseus and moving on to the Trojan War and the horse that brought it all to an end. My kids knew nothing about ancient Greece, but they loved a good story, especially one that used guile to overcome danger. They remember those stories still and use them as cultural references when life throws problems.

So, should we give children only stories set in familiar territories and times? Should we keep tales to their well-known stereotypes, the paths they know well? But why water their minds on such thin ground? I think we should take their imaginations to new and fertile lands. Let them grow.

Comments

We're all foreigners somewhere

Most of us don’t think of ourselves as foreigners, even when we’re overseas. We believe that we are one with the wider group. After all, foreigners are something else, they are the people who don’t belong. I remember the first time I realised I was be an outsider. My British Caledonian flight to Zambia had landed in Lusaka and, when I looked out onto the tarmac, none of the ground staff looked like me. It gave me a thrill but also a sense of vulnerability. These people were not my people and I wondered if I would be safe among them. That thought prompted another – this is how visitors to my own country must feel. They are outnumbered, and their dress, skin colour, hair, any number of things, mark them out and perhaps leave them open to hostility. I have to say that I met no hostility in Zambia. Instead, my social skills grew as I learned to reach out to the people I lived among. Perhaps I did it to fit in, to ensure that I was less of a foreigner. I didn’t anticipate feeling ...

If no one ever left home Think of a world where no one ever travelled. One where we knew all our neighbours, our landscapes, and we shared the same philosophy on life. In this world we would know nothing of what lay over a hillside, behind a mountain or across the sea. Some people in this world, they are perfectly happy here. Personally, I feel smothered even writing that description. Travel is as much about considering new ideas as it is about taking a photo or buying a t-shirt. My first trip overseas was magical although perhaps not in some people's eyes. I travelled from Scotland to Greece by bus - four days of looking out of the window onto a foreign world, my very own vista. It was dawn when we reached the Greek border, the hillsides were golden and, as I looked around, I would not have been surprised to see a shepherd and his nymphs frolicking downhill toward me. No matter the long bus journey, I had arrived into a magical land. The children of The Lion, the Witch and ...

To guide or not to guide

The mobile phone has made travel easier. Not only can we contact our loved ones more easily, tell them we’re in trouble, ask for help, or simply tell them that we miss them, but the mobile phone gives us access to maps, a compass, and guides on where to eat and places to stay. When I began travelling, which was in the dark ages before the internet, I would write to a country’s tourist board and tell them what part of their country I wanted to visit. They would send me a stack of brochures, and I would pour over the photos and the text for months ahead of our trip. My friends were not so engaged. All they wanted was sun and they left the planning to me. Looking back, there wasn’t a lot of planning. We’d take the bus from the old airport in Athens to Piraeus, step into any of the ferry offices and buy a ticket to an island. We didn’t ask where to find the ferry but would walk along the port side yelling at anyone on board each boat: “Paros”, “Crete” or wherever. Most times we w...

Travel now not tomorrow

Search This Blog